Home About Us Media Kit Subscriptions Links Forum
EDUCATION UPDATE BLOGS
DSM-5 Minor Neurocognitive Disorder — Let's Wait For Accurate Biological Tests - Dr. Allen Frances

DSM-5 Minor Neurocognitive Disorder — Let's Wait For Accurate Biological Tests

  |   Comments   |   Bookmark and Share
Within the next three to five years, we will likely have biological tests to accurately diagnose the prodrome of Alzheimer's disease (AD). Much remains to be done in standardizing these tests, determining their appropriate set points and patterns of results, and negotiating the difficult transition from research to general clinical practice. And, given the lack of effective treatment, there are legitimate concerns about the advisability of testing for the individual patient and the enormous societal expense with little tangible benefit. Despite these necessary caveats, there is no doubt that biological testing for prodromal AD will be an important milestone in the clinical application of neuroscience.

How does this impact on the DSM-5 proposal to include a Minor Neurocognitive Disorder as a presumed prodrome to AD? Clearly the advancing science makes this proposal obviously premature and unnecessary. Any DSM-5 definition has necessarily to be based exclusively on extremely fallible clinical criteria that will have unacceptably high false positive rates — surely exceeding 50 percent. Why scare half the people taking the tests unnecessarily, especially when there is no effective treatment even for those who are true positives?

Accurate diagnosis for prodromal AD most certainly requires biological tests and, fortunately, these are now well within reach. No purpose can possibly be served by rushing ahead with a second rate clinical method of prodrome diagnosis when accurate biological testing will so soon be available. DSM-5 can make a far better choice. It has declared itself to be a 'living document' with plans for continuing, ongoing revision as new findings justify changes. Prodromal AD is the perfect diagnosis for implementing this plan. Hold off for now and then add an Alzheimer's prodrome only after the biological tests have proven themselves able to diagnose it accurately.

Leave a comment

Recent Entries

The Role of Biological Tests In Psychiatric Diagnosis
May has been a dispiriting month for psychiatry and a sad and worrying time for our patients. Three of the…
The British Psychological Society Enters the Silly Season
The British Psychological Society has issued a press release that rivals the sillyness of DSM 5 and the National Institute…
NIMH vs. DSM 5: No One Wins, Patients Lose
The flat out rejection of DSM 5 by National Institute of Mental Health is a sad moment for mental health…
OpenID accepted here Learn more about OpenID
Education Update, Inc. All material is copyrighted and may not be printed without express consent of the publisher. © 2011.